Our take
The Sunbeam 5891 is a preset bread maker with 1.5 lb and 2 lb selections and dedicated Whole Wheat, Dough, Jam, and Cake programs. Its 58-minute ExpressBake gives time-pressed bakers another option, but Sunbeam describes a shorter, denser loaf with a darker, thicker crust. ExpressBake cannot be delayed or crust-adjusted, so it is a special-purpose shortcut rather than a substitute for every standard bake.
For bakers who want 1.5 lb or 2 lb loaves and dedicated Dough, Jam, and Cake modes, and who can treat ExpressBake as a texture tradeoff..
Not for shoppers who require a dedicated Gluten-Free setting, an automatic ingredient dispenser, a documented ceramic pan, or verified current Amazon availability.
Pros & cons
What could work for you, and what to consider before buying.
What works in its favor
- The manual documents selectable 1.5 lb and 2 lb loaf sizes.
- Whole Wheat, Dough, Jam, and Cake each have named menu settings.
- ExpressBake takes 58 minutes for either listed loaf size.
What to weigh up
- ExpressBake cannot use the delay timer or crust-color selection.
- Its fast loaves are described as denser, shorter, and more darkly crusted.
- Pan coating, compact dimensions, and exact power-recovery behavior remain unknown.
The key details
| Model covered | 5891 |
|---|---|
| Loaf size | Selectable 1.5 lb and 2 lb sizes |
| Specialty programs | Twelve preset programs include Whole Wheat, Dough, Jam, and Cake |
| Timing and control | 13-hour delay on eligible cycles; ExpressBake is 58 minutes |
Performance figures are manufacturer claims. Source checked October 1, 2026. Regional models and included accessories can differ.
What the features mean for you
A named 5891 with a part-number crosswalk
Sunbeam's manual index associates part number 005891-000-000 with the programmable bread-maker manual, whose cover identifies model 5891. This supports one model profile for candidate strings 005891-000-000 and 5891. The historical candidate rows remain evidence of old listings only: the inspected material does not map their ASINs to a current seller offer, bundle, or condition. The purchase link therefore searches the exact model.
Two loaf sizes and a broad preset menu
The control panel offers 1.5 lb and 2 lb settings. Its twelve named selections include Basic, French, Whole Wheat, Quick, Sweet, two ExpressBake sizes, Dough, Jam, Cake, Sandwich, and Bake. Standard bread programs offer light, medium, and dark crust choices. The full list has no dedicated Gluten-Free cycle, even though a shopper can adapt other recipes; the manual's named-menu evidence is the basis for this profile.
What the 58-minute option gives up
ExpressBake takes 58 minutes for either listed size, an unusually short schedule compared with the standard cycles. Sunbeam warns that the result tends to be denser and shorter, with a darker and thicker crust. The setting does not allow crust-color adjustment or delayed start. Use it when time matters more than loaf height or a softer crust, and follow the manual's fast-cycle ingredient directions rather than assuming the ordinary recipe is interchangeable.
Scheduling and routine limits
The delay timer reaches 13 hours on eligible programs, and automatic Keep Warm lasts up to one hour. The manual advises against delaying recipes containing perishable ingredients such as eggs or milk. ExpressBake is excluded from the timer, and the machine must cool before beginning another cycle. This makes scheduled standard baking more flexible than the fast mode and favors one batch at a time over back-to-back baking.
Unknown details should stay unknown
The manual identifies one kneading blade and a nonstick pan, but a later care section contradicts the overview's dishwasher wording, so dishwasher safety is not used as a matching claim. The coating composition, external dimensions, and loaf orientation are not established. An ambiguous outage sentence also does not give a reliable recovery threshold. Buyers who require those details should check the exact machine and its included manual before relying on them.
What else to compare
Before you buy
Which loaf sizes are selectable?
The Sunbeam manual shows 1.5 lb and 2 lb selections on the control panel.
Does the 5891 have a dedicated Gluten-Free program?
No. The complete twelve-setting menu does not list a dedicated Gluten-Free bread cycle.
How long does ExpressBake take?
The manual lists 58 minutes for both loaf sizes and warns that the result is denser and often shorter.
Can ExpressBake be delayed?
No. Sunbeam excludes ExpressBake from the delay timer and from crust-color adjustment.
Where can I check the current price?
Use the Amazon link for current offers. Check the exact model, seller, product condition, delivery, and return terms. This page does not display a live price or confirm stock.
Sources & review basis
We use the following manufacturer documentation for the product features above. Our suitability notes and buying advice are editorial judgments based on those features, not measured performance results.
- Sunbeam 5891 breadmaker user manual ↗ — checked October 1, 2026.
- Sunbeam manual index mapping part number 005891-000-000 ↗ — checked October 1, 2026.
- Sunbeam 5891 instruction manual; controls, cycles, timer, and care ↗ — checked October 1, 2026.
The decision
The Sunbeam 5891 is a preset bread maker with 1.5 lb and 2 lb selections and dedicated Whole Wheat, Dough, Jam, and Cake programs. Its 58-minute ExpressBake gives time-pressed bakers another option, but Sunbeam describes a shorter, denser loaf with a darker, thicker crust. ExpressBake cannot be delayed or crust-adjusted, so it is a special-purpose shortcut rather than a substitute for every standard bake.
Is it the right fit?
Check the exact model and today’s offers on Amazon.