Our take
Consider ETO-1231 if you want a settings display, named oven modes, automatic convection on Bake, Pizza, and Cookie, or the maker catalog's six-slice and 12-inch pizza claims. Plan for four inches of clearance and treat retailer-specific details carefully.
Consider it for documented convection modes and catalog-stated food uses when four-inch spacing works..
Not for Air Fry, rotisserie, a required custom cooking program, measured pan or counter fit, or a maker-confirmed wattage, finish, or current offer.
Pros & cons
What could work for you, and what to consider before buying.
What works in its favor
- The manual shows an LCD with separate function and time/temperature controls.
- Convection activates automatically for Bake, Pizza, and Cookie according to the manual.
- The maker catalog lists six modes and six-slice / 12-inch pizza uses.
What to weigh up
- The sources disagree about whether the oven is programmable; no custom sequence is documented.
- There is no complete temperature range, cavity measurement, or exterior dimension.
- The 120 V / 1,500 W and Stainless descriptions belong to Best Buy's exact-model record, not a maker nameplate.
The key details
| Model covered | ETO-1231 |
|---|---|
| Documented cooking modes | Bake, Broil, Toast, Pizza, Cookie, and Warm appear in the Maxi-Matic catalog. |
| Published food-fit reference | Maker catalog claims six slices and up to 12-inch pizza; these are not cavity measurements. |
| Controls and timer | LCD, Function knob, Time/Temp knob, and Start/Stop button; timed procedures run up to 120 minutes. |
| Placement and electrical notes | Manual asks for four inches at sides, back, and top; Best Buy attributes 120 V / 1,500 W to its record. |
| Source and variant boundary | Programmability and brand/finish clues conflict; historic ASIN and present offer remain unmapped. |
Performance figures are manufacturer claims. Source checked October 8, 2026. Regional models and included accessories can differ.
What the features mean for you
An LCD sits beside physical controls
The manual identifies an LCD display, a Function adjust knob, a Time/Temp adjust knob, and a Start/Stop button. That combination lets the user see settings while still making selections with a knob. Maxi-Matic's catalog lists Bake, Broil, Toast, Pizza, Cookie, and Warm. Best Buy's function field lists a shorter set, so the six-mode list is attributed to the maker catalog. Keep the frozen row's Elite Gourmet clue and the retailer's Maxi Matic attribution separate from the manual's Elite Platinum model identity.
Convection is automatic on three procedures
For Bake, Pizza, and Cookie, the manual says convection heat activates automatically. That matters if you want fan-assisted baking without choosing a separate Convection-only setting. The manual shows upper and lower elements but does not provide a complete element-by-mode map. The catalog also lists Broil, Toast, and Warm. Neither the exact manual nor the listed mode set supports Air Fry or Rotisserie, so those should not be inferred from general convection wording or unrelated models.
Use the stated food fit as a claim, not a measurement
Maxi-Matic's catalog says the oven accommodates six bread slices and pizzas up to 12 inches. These statements can help compare named tasks, but they are not measured cavity dimensions or proof that any 12-inch pan will fit. The manual gives no exterior dimensions or full temperature span, and a Best Buy answer mentions dimensions without serving as an inspected cavity measurement. If a pan, counter opening, or handle clearance is critical, check the actual cookware and appliance before buying.
Timer and placement limits are clearer
For Bake, Pizza, and Cookie, the manual allows settings from one to 120 minutes. Maxi-Matic's catalog describes a two-hour timer with a bell and automatic shutoff. The manual asks for a dry, level surface and at least four inches at the sides, back, and top. It does not provide a complete thermostat range, and no source confirms under-cabinet installation. Best Buy lists 120 V and 1,500 W for the exact code; wattage stays retailer-attributed rather than being presented as a nameplate fact.
Do not rely on a custom program or old offer match
The manual title calls ETO-1231 programmable, but Best Buy marks its Programmable field false. No custom multi-stage sequence is documented in the inspected instructions. Best Buy also titles the model Stainless Steel and lists a four-function field, while Maxi-Matic's catalog describes six functions; these source roles should stay visible. The old Silver/Black clue and historical ASIN are not connected to a current listing. This is a source-based review, not a claim of hands-on testing or buyer experience.
What else to compare
ETO-730SS also lists a 12-inch frozen-pizza procedure but uses manual controls; Bialetti 35047 has digital presets with a documented Reheat fan-setting conflict.
Before you buy
Does ETO-1231 have an LCD?
Yes. The exact-model manual identifies an LCD, Function adjust knob, Time/Temp adjust knob, and Start/Stop button.
Is it confirmed to save custom programs?
No. The manual title says programmable, but Best Buy's field conflicts and the guide does not document a custom sequence.
What does the pizza-fit claim establish?
The maker catalog says up to 12 inches; it does not give cavity measurements or guarantee arbitrary pan fit.
Where can I check the current price?
Use the Amazon link for current offers. Check the exact model, seller, product condition, delivery, and return terms. This page does not display a live price or confirm stock.
Sources & review basis
We use the following manufacturer documentation for the product features above. Our suitability notes and buying advice are editorial judgments based on those features, not measured performance results.
- Elite Platinum ETO-1231 instruction manual ↗ — checked October 8, 2026.
- Elite Platinum ETO-1231 instruction manual ↗ — checked October 8, 2026.
- Maxi-Matic USA product catalog ↗ — checked October 8, 2026.
- Best Buy exact-model ETO-1231 record ↗ — checked October 8, 2026.
The decision
Choose ETO-1231 for the display and its documented automatic-convection modes when the catalog food-fit claims and four-inch spacing suit you. Do not count on custom programming or a specific current finish.
Is it the right fit?
Check the exact model and today’s offers on Amazon.